Paid in Kind, Taxed in Time: Company Cars and Medical Cover Move to Payroll

For much of history, what people owed was paid in kind rather than in coin. A tenant might hand over a share of the harvest, a few days’ labour, or a hen at Christmas. The reckoning came later. Each year the king’s sheriffs stood before the Exchequer at Michaelmas, where accounts were settled with counters on a chequered cloth and notched tally sticks.

Benefits in kind have worked in much the same way for decades. A company car or private medical cover is enjoyed all year round, but the reckoning comes afterwards, on a P11D filed the following July.

From 6 April 2027 that changes. HMRC wants the tax on the most common benefits worked out and paid as you go, through payroll, every pay day. If you run your own payroll and provide company cars, vans, fuel or medical cover, this affects you, and the time to prepare is now.

What’s changing

At the moment, most employers report benefits in kind once a year, after the tax year ends, on forms P11D and P11D(b). The employee pays the tax through an adjustment to their tax code, usually based on an estimate, and the employer pays its Class 1A National Insurance in one sum each July.

Under payrolling, the taxable value of each benefit is spread across the year and added to the employee’s pay each pay period. The tax comes off their pay in the normal way, and the employer’s Class 1A National Insurance is reported and paid alongside its usual PAYE. For example, a monthly paid employee with a benefit worth £2,100 for the year would have £175 added to their taxable pay each month.

HMRC is bringing this in over two stages:

Stage Starts Benefits included
One 6 April 2027 Company cars, fuel for company cars, vans, fuel for vans, and employer-provided medical benefits such as private medical insurance
Two 6 April 2028 Most other benefits in kind

Employment-related loans and living accommodation aren’t included in either stage for now. They can stay on the P11D or be payrolled voluntarily.

There is no need to register with HMRC for the first stage. It simply becomes the way these benefits are dealt with, and HMRC will take the benefits out of your employees’ tax codes before 6 April 2027 so that nobody is taxed twice on the same thing.

What it means in practice

A double helping of Class 1A in July 2027

This is the point most likely to catch people out. In July 2027 you will still pay the Class 1A National Insurance on benefits for the year to 5 April 2027, under the old P11D system. Over the same months you will also be paying Class 1A each month on the new year’s benefits. For that one year the two overlap. At the current rate of 15%, a company car with a taxable value of £6,000 means £900 of Class 1A, so the overlap can add up quickly. It is worth allowing for it in your budget now.

Payslips and the “paying tax twice” worry

Your employees’ payslips will show the value of the benefit, and their tax codes will change. HMRC won’t remove any tax still owed from earlier years from tax codes, so an employee who is catching up on an old underpayment may feel they are paying tax twice. They aren’t. They are paying this year’s tax as they go while finishing off an earlier year. A short note to the people affected before April will save a lot of questions.

Changes during the year

A new car, a car handed back, a change in medical cover, or someone joining or leaving will need to go through payroll when it happens, rather than being sorted out at the year end. When the value changes, the revised figure for the year is spread over the remaining pay periods.

Contributions and making good

Where an employee pays towards a benefit, for example by reimbursing the cost of private fuel, the amount payrolled can be reduced by what they are reasonably expected to pay. Employees still have until 6 July after the tax year ends to make good, and any adjustment can be made through payroll afterwards.

Estimates are allowed

If you don’t have an exact figure at the start of the year, a reasonable estimate can be used and corrected later in the year. HMRC’s own example is using last year’s value for a similar benefit. What it doesn’t want is for employers to leave everything until the year end.

The P11D isn’t dead yet

For the year ending 5 April 2027, all benefits are still reported on P11D and P11D(b) in the usual way, by 6 July 2027, with the Class 1A paid by 22 July. For 2027/28, anything outside the first stage still goes on a P11D unless you choose to payroll it voluntarily. So for a year or two, many employers will be running both systems side by side.

If you already payroll benefits voluntarily, or would like to

If you are already registered with HMRC to payroll benefits, your registration carries on automatically for 2027/28. One thing does change: from April 2027, the Class 1A on any voluntarily payrolled benefits must also be paid through payroll each month. You can’t payroll the tax and leave the Class 1A for the year end. If you would rather go back to P11Ds for benefits outside the first stage, the registration needs to be withdrawn by 5 April 2027.

If you would like to start payrolling other benefits voluntarily from April 2027, so that you only have one system to run, HMRC’s registration service opens in November 2026 and closes on 5 April 2027.

A soft landing on penalties

HMRC has said that for 2027/28 it won’t charge penalties for errors in payrolled benefit figures unless there is evidence that they are deliberate. That is welcome breathing space, but it only covers mistakes in the figures. The normal penalties and interest for filing or paying late still apply from day one.

Getting ready

April 2027 may feel a long way off, but HMRC is clear that the work takes longer than people expect. A few sensible steps over the coming months:

  1. List the benefits you provide and which employees receive them, and mark which fall into the first stage.
  2. Gather the details payroll will need for each company car: list price, CO2 emissions, fuel type and the date it was first made available.
  3. Check with your payroll software provider that the software will be ready for April 2027. If you use HMRC’s own Basic PAYE Tools, HMRC has confirmed it will be updated.
  4. Decide who will tell payroll when something changes. If you provide fuel, think about how fuel card information will reach payroll in time for each pay run.
  5. Allow for the July 2027 overlap in your cash flow.
  6. Let the employees affected know what to expect, ideally before April.

No more waiting for Michaelmas

The old annual reckoning is giving way to a running account, settled each pay day. Done properly, it means fewer surprises for your employees and no more year-end scramble for P11D figures. The first year is likely to be the trickiest.

If you’d like a hand going through the benefits you provide, working out the figures to go into payroll, or looking at the effect on your cash flow, call us on 0333 880 1915 or get in touch.

Useful links